Agenda item
Planning Applications
- Meeting of Planning Committee, Thursday, 28th June, 2018 10.00 am (Item P.6)
- View the declarations of interest for item P.6
Report of the Deputy Chief Executive.
Please note that plans are available to view on the Council's website through the Public Access facility.
Minutes:
The Committee considered reports of the Deputy Chief Executive relating to applications for planning permission. During the meeting, Officers referred to additional information and representations which had been received.
Except where an alternative condition was contained in the report or an amendment made by the Committee, the condition as set out in the report and the appropriate time limit conditions were to be attached in accordance with the relevant provisions of Section 91 and 92 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.
The abbreviated conditions and reasons shown in the report were to be set out in full on the notices of decision. It was noted that following consideration by the Committee, and without further reference to the Committee, the Deputy Chief Executive had delegated authority to add, delete or amend conditions and reasons for refusal.
In considering the report(s) of the Deputy Chief Executive regard had been paid to the policies of the relevant development plan, the National Planning Policy Framework and all other material planning considerations. Where the Committee deferred consideration or refused planning permission the reasons for that decision are as shown in the report or as set out below.
Where the Committee granted planning permission in accordance with the recommendation in a report this was because the proposal is in accordance with the development plan the National Planning Policy Framework or other material considerations as set out in the report unless otherwise specified below. Where the Committee granted planning permission contrary to the recommendation in the report the reasons for doing so and the conditions to be attached are set out below.
THE DECISION:
That the applications be determined in accordance with the recommendation in the report of the Deputy Chief Executive, unless shown otherwise:-
(1) 18/00760/OUT - Outline application for two dwellings with details of access (all other matters reserved) at Land adjacent 91 Bedale Road, Aiskew for Mr J Yates
PERMISSION GRANTED subject to North Yorkshire County Council’s Highways advice and a condition restricting the development to consist of two bungalows. Permission granted because the Committee felt the development was in a sustainable location and would not cause harm to the countryside.
The decision was contrary to the recommendation of the Deputy Chief Executive.
(The applicant’s agent, Zoe Harrison, spoke in support of the application).
(2) 18/00116/FUL - Construction of 3 terrace houses (2 x 3 bedroom and 1 x 4 bedroom) and associated works, parking and formation of new vehicle access at Land north east of 6 School Terrace, Carlton Road, Carlton Miniott for Jean Wood
PERMISSION GRANTED
(3) 17/02490/FUL - Construction of five detached dwellings at Land at the rear of the Moor and Pheasant Public House, Dalton for Moor and Pheasant Ltd
PERMISSION REFUSED with an additional reason for refusal that the loss of the existing use of the site would have a detrimental impact on local economy.
(The applicant’s agent, Andrew Burningham, spoke in support of the application).
(4) 18/00423/FUL - Construction of one dwelling at Ivy House, Dalton for Mr Wood
DEFER for a flood risk assessment and further consideration of the proposed access.
(5) 18/00494/FUL - Construction of a slurry pit at Land south west of Low Brockholme Farm, Streetlam for H Pattison Partners
PERMISSION GRANTED because the Committee felt that the benefits of the proposed agricultural practice and its location outweighed the harm to the countryside subject to landscaping conditions.
The decision was contrary to the recommendation of the Deputy Chief Executive.
(The applicant’s agent, Paul Dennison, spoke in support of the application).
(6) 18/00661/FUL - Change of use of storage/workshop to furniture manufacture, repair and refurbishment and textile manufacture with ancillary retail use at Summersgill Auctioneers, Unit 1, Roxby House Business Park, York Road, Easingwold for Mr T Summersgill
PERMISSION GRANTED
Disclosure of Interest
Councillor D A Webster disclosed a personal interest as his spouse is related to the applicant and left the meeting prior to discussion and voting on this item.
(7) 18/00810/FUL - Retrospective change of use from office (B1 use) to a dwellinghouse (C3 use) at 1 Hawkhills Drive, Easingwold for Serco Limited
PERMISSION GRANTED
The meeting adjourned at 11.35am and reconvened at 1.30pm
Councillor Mrs B S Fortune in attendance at the meeting from 1.30pm
(8) 18/00414/FUL - Construction of a dwelling at Land at Raby Lane, East Cowton for Mr Rawlins
PERMISSION GRANTED subject to officers receiving confirmation from Yorkshire Water on matters of surface water and foul water disposal.
(Kenneth Smith spoke objecting to the application.)
(9) 18/00701/OUT - Outline application (with some matters reserved) for a dwelling with integral garage at Ashdale, Gracious Street, Huby for Mr Cahill
PERMISSION GRANTED
(10) 18/00788/MRC - Variation of conditions attached to planning permission 16/02127/FUL - construction of three dwellings and associated works (revision to planning application 16/01540/FUL) at Land to the south of Bravener Court, Newton on Ouse for A.T. Lee Properties Ltd
PERMISSION GRANTED
(The applicant’s agent, Mr Steel, spoke in support of the application).
Disclosure of Interest
Councillor C Rooke disclosed a pecuniary interest and left the meeting prior to discussion and voting on this item.
(11) 18/00733/FUL - Conversion of barn/stables unit to single dwelling at Pear Tree Cottage, Raskelf for Mr and Mrs Lee
PERMISSION GRANTED
(12) 17/01653/FUL - Retrospective application for an extension to a biomass building at Busby Stoop Farm, Skipton Old Airfield, Sandhutton for Richard Maxwell Ltd
PERMISSION GRANTED subject to conditions relating to control of noise and other matters. The Committee felt that adequate protection of residential amenity could be achieved through conditions.
The decision was contrary to the recommendation of the Deputy Chief Executive.
(Councillor Janet Watson spoke on behalf of Sandhutton Parish Council objecting to the application.)
(13) 17/01855/FUL - Retrospective siting of a detached biomass building at Moose Turkey Farm, Skipton Old Airfield, Sandhutton for Richard Maxwell Ltd
PERMISSION GRANTED
(14) 17/01863/FUL - Retrospective application for the construction of a detached biomass building and associated parking at Swale Turkey Farm, Skipton Old Airfield, Sandhutton for Richard Maxwell Ltd
PERMISSION GRANTED
(15) 17/01856/FUL - Retrospective application for the construction of a detached biomass building and associated parking at Sandybank Turkey Farm, Skipton Old Airfield, Sandhutton for Richard Maxwell Ltd
PERMISSION GRANTED
(16) 17/01866/FUL - Retrospective application for the construction of a detached biomass building and associated parking at North Turkey Farm, Skipton Old Airfield, Sandhutton for Richard Maxwell Ltd
PERMISSION GRANTED
(17) 18/00825/FUL - Retrospective storage of logs for woodchipping, operation of mobile wood chipper and weighbridge at Busby Stoop Farm, Skipton Old Airfield, Sandhutton for Richard Maxwell Ltd
DEFER to allow preparation of a noise report and appropriate mitigation measures.
(Councillor Janet Watson spoke on behalf of Sandhutton Parish Council objecting to the application.)
(Councillor Gareth Dadd spoke on behalf of an objector objecting to the application.)
(18) 17/02612/FUL - Construction of one detached dwellinghouse at Stokesley Used Car Sales, Tame Bridge for Mr Da Silva
PERMISSION REFUSED as the Committee had concerns regarding drainage on the site, the size and massing of the proposed development and the amenity impact on future residents of the proposed dwelling from commercial premises to the rear of the site.
The decision was contrary to the recommendation of the Deputy Chief Executive.
(The applicant’s agent, Ian Lyle, spoke in support of the application).
(19) 16/00755/OUT - Outline planning application for the construction of a detached dwelling with garage and access drive at The Laurels, Main Street, Tollerton for Miss Lynne Dawson
PERMISSION GRANTED
Note: Councillor D A Webster left the meeting at 4.30pm prior to discussion and voting on item 20
(20) 17/01321/FUL - Demolition of garages and construction of a four bedroom dwelling at Walkers Ground, Church Street, Topcliffe for Ms Jacqui Collyns
PERMISSION REFUSED
(The applicant’s agent, Anne Johnson, spoke in support of the application).
(21) 17/01320/LBC - Listed building consent for the demolition of garages at Walkers Ground, Church Street, Topcliffe for Ms Jacqui Collyns
PERMISSION GRANTED
Supporting documents:
- Plans List Cover sheet, item P.6 PDF 46 KB
- Plans List June 28th, item P.6 PDF 64 KB
- Item 1 - 18-00760-OUT - Land adj 91 Bedale Road, Aiskew, item P.6 PDF 39 KB
- Item 2 - 18-00116-FUL Land North East Of 6 School Terrace, Carlton Miniott, item P.6 PDF 68 KB
- Item 3 - 17-02490-FUL - Moor and Pheasant, Dalton, item P.6 PDF 66 KB
- Item 4 - 18-00423- Ivy House, Dalton, item P.6 PDF 57 KB
- Item 5 - 18-00494-FUL Brockholme Farm Streetlam, item P.6 PDF 35 KB
- Item 6 - 18-00661-FUL - Summersgill Auctioneers, item P.6 PDF 43 KB
- Item 7 - 18-00810-FUL 1 Hawkhills Drive, Easingwold, item P.6 PDF 49 KB
- Item 8 - 18-00414-FUL - Raby Lane, East Cowton, item P.6 PDF 69 KB
- Item 9 - 18-00701-OUT Ashdale, Huby, item P.6 PDF 56 KB
- Item 10 - 18-00788-MRC Land to the South of Bravener Court, Newton on Ouse, item P.6 PDF 49 KB
- Item 11 - 18-00733-Pear Tree Cottage Raskelf, item P.6 PDF 48 KB
- Item 12 - 17.01653.FUL Busby Stoop Farm, item P.6 PDF 35 KB
- Item 13 - 17.01855.FUL - Moose Turkey Farm, item P.6 PDF 37 KB
- Item 14 - 17.01863.FUL - Swale Turkey Farm, Skipton Old Airfield, item P.6 PDF 37 KB
- Item 15 - 17.01856.FUL - Sandybank Farm, Skipton Old Airfield, item P.6 PDF 37 KB
- Item 16 - 17.01866.FUL - North Turkey Farm Sheds, Skipton Old Airfield, item P.6 PDF 29 KB
- Item 17 - 18.00825.FUL - Busby Stoop Farm & North Turkey Farm, Sandhutton, item P.6 PDF 52 KB
- Item 18 - 17-02612-FUL Stokesley Used Car Sales, Tame Bridge, item P.6 PDF 65 KB
- Item 19 - 16.00755.OUT - The Laurels, Main Street, Tollerton, item P.6 PDF 38 KB
- Item 20 & 21 - 17.01321.FUL & 17.03020.LBC - Walkers Ground, Topcliffe, item P.6 PDF 43 KB